Ombudsman’s robo-debt report in 2017 ‘formed’ by bureaucrat in command of managing the disaster

A spokesperson for the Ombudsman mentioned the physique recurrently despatched drafts to companies for them to make feedback on, nonetheless, the “type of a printed report is a matter for the Ombudsman to determine.”


Showing earlier than former Queensland Supreme Court docket justice Catherine Holmes in Brisbane, McNamara was proven correspondence that included DHS proposing rewrites of findings and suggestions in Ombudsman draft reviews, together with a proposal the watchdog strike out wording that “inaccurate money owed” have been raised.

“Our authorized division didn’t like that in any respect,” McNamara mentioned. “They didn’t agree with it as a matter of legislation that it was an inaccurate debt, in order that they didn’t need that within the report.”

The recommended amendments additionally eliminated findings that debt notices didn’t present a transparent “warning that utilizing averaged information might end in an incorrect debt”, and inserted language that forged the division in a greater gentle.

It was put to McNamara that intensive negotiation with the Ombudsman’s workplace befell over the report, to which he replied, “yeah, they have been open to alter.”

He mentioned the report was then used to counter detrimental press, describing it as an “exterior reference that was very helpful”.

“It was a tactic utilized in a really tough political surroundings,” he mentioned.


Authorities Providers Minister Invoice Shorten mentioned after immediately’s proof: “It’s a poor reflection on the Liberals that their public service felt they needed to whitewash to please the previous authorities.”

Earlier, senior counsel helping the fee Justin Greggery KC mentioned related former Morrison authorities ministers together with Mr Tudge, Stuart Robert, Christian Porter, Dan Tehan and Paul Fletcher are prone to be known as to offer proof.

The social providers and human providers ministers on the time the scheme was established – Scott Morrison and Marise Payne respectively – are already scheduled to entrance hearings subsequent week.

Payne will give proof subsequent Tuesday earlier than Mr Morrison takes the stand on Wednesday.

Reduce by means of the noise of federal politics with information, views and skilled evaluation from Jacqueline Maley. Subscribers can signal as much as our weekly Inside Politics e-newsletter right here.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles