Qatar’s high-spend World Cup, by Akram Belkaïd (Le Monde diplomatique

JPEG - 459.9 kb


Venice? Inside of the Village Mall in Doha, prepared for the World Cup, 12 October 2022

Giuseppe Cacace · AFP · Getty

When, in December 2010, the manager committee of FIFA, the worldwide soccer federation, selected Qatar to host the 2022 World Cup, its capital Doha erupted in delight. Ships in port sounded their horns and costly automobiles on the corniche joined in. Qatari media celebrated their nation changing into a part of the massive league. Emir Hamad bin Khalifa al-Thani, who dominated the emirate till he abdicated in 2013, was overjoyed that its title could be recognized worldwide.

However criticism started instantly. The footballing fraternity condemned holding the World Cup in a parched desert nation with no enthusiasm for the sport. The US, which had misplaced the FIFA vote by 14 to eight — regardless of being positive it might win — blamed it on bribery and corruption. And NGOs criticised the authoritarianism of this rich gas-rich emirate which bans political events and commerce unions. Amnesty Worldwide’s 2011 report on the human rights state of affairs in Qatar wrote, ‘Ladies continued to face discrimination and violence. Migrant staff had been exploited and abused, and inadequately protected underneath the regulation. Round 100 individuals remained arbitrarily disadvantaged of their nationality. Sentences of flogging had been handed. Demise sentences continued to be upheld, though no executions had been carried out.’ That stated all of it.

Or maybe not fairly: over the subsequent 12 years, the Qatar 2022 story has rumbled on, with judicial investigations within the US and France into FIFA’s extremely controversial choice and corruption inside its management; eye-opening reviews on the dreadful situation of staff from Asia (Bangladesh, India, Nepal, Pakistan, the Philippines) and Africa (Kenya, Somalia and Sudan); and condemnation of the environmental harm attributable to constructing six air-conditioned stadiums.

The record of expenses grew longer by the month, however with out ever critically threatening the venue’s choice. As with the 1978 World Cup, held in Argentina whereas underneath a navy junta, the uncommon requires a boycott failed. Qatar stored its head down and pumped tens of thousands and thousands of {dollars} into image-boosting PR; in the meantime its $200bn infrastructure price range (together with a metro system) delighted a whole lot of Western, Chinese language and Japanese corporations.

Outrage from overseas

With the competitors because of kick off on 20 November, the criticism has reached new heights. Apparently, it’s by no means too late to chip in, and everybody desires to specific their outrage. On 22 September François Hollande stated, ‘Given what we all know concerning the circumstances underneath which this competitors can be held, each when it comes to local weather and building work, if I had been head of state — which I not am, so it’s simple for me to say — I wouldn’t go to Qatar.’ When he was president, he had no such qualms. On an official go to to Doha in June 2013 he even promised that France would assist Qatar ‘organise a extremely nice World Cup’. On the time, the unenviable lot of the Asian staff who had been constructing Qatar and the opposite Gulf oil states for many years was already broadly recognized. However Hollande, on a mission to promote Rafale fighter planes, wasn’t unduly involved.

Paris’s metropolis corridor has additionally immediately began supporting staff in Qatar and has determined there can be no ‘fan zone’ for exhibiting matches in public areas through the competitors. ‘I condemn any collusion with states that don’t at the moment respect local weather points, social guidelines or the rule of regulation, that are basic,’ stated deputy mayor David Belliard, defending this daring boycott. The place does that depart Paris Saint-Germain Soccer Membership? It has been Qatari-owned since 2011 and its president, Nasser al-Khelaifi, an in depth affiliate of the present emir, Tamim al-Thani, commonly invitations Paris’s mayor, Anne Hidalgo, to the VIP stand on the Parc des Princes. Broadcaster TF1 has determined to not point out Qatar in its World Cup trailers — although it should, after all, nonetheless present the matches.

If Qatar deserves to be boycotted, so too do all of the Gulf monarchies, from Saudi Arabia to Oman — and have accomplished for a very long time. Tons of of staff died constructing Qatari World Cup websites, however many others had already died in Dubai within the 2000s whereas establishing the Burj Khalifa, one of many world’s highest towers. Its panoramic summit now attracts tens of hundreds of vacationers of all nationalities; and there’s no discuss of a boycotting it.

In Oman, the development of the brand new metropolis of Duqm has concerned armies of overseas staff, whose circumstances are scarcely higher than these in Qatar, however nobody has proposed shelving the favored Oman Biking Tour. Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Bahrain are always underneath fireplace for failing to respect human rights, their function within the conflict in Yemen and the autocratic manner they’re run. However nobody is suggesting boycotting their Components 1 Grand Prix. Nor have there been objections to 2 biking groups, one financed by the UAE and the opposite by Bahrain, competing within the Tour de France.

And what about environmental harm accomplished extra broadly by Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) members? Six air-conditioned stadiums for the World Cup are an environmental catastrophe, sure, however how do they examine to the hundreds of tonnes of hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) launched by the air-conditioning vegetation which make life in Qatar bearable from March to October? In 2016, at a global summit in Kigali, Rwanda, following intense lobbying, the Gulf states secured a postponement of the CFC ban till 2047 (it’s 2036 for different international locations). Nonetheless, there’s no indication they’ll meet this deadline. In Abu Dhabi, huge motels chill their swimming swimming pools in summer time. In Dubai, you may ski all yr spherical in a French-designed indoor resort. This huge consumption of power is masked by intelligent PR promising inexperienced know-how. The Worldwide Renewable Power Company is even based mostly in an oil large, the UAE.

A storm of protest

In internet hosting the World Cup, Qatar is discovering the value of getting ambitions on the worldwide stage. It’s one factor to play host to regional sporting occasions or, as in 2001, the World Commerce Organisation’s ministerial convention, which offered a handy manner of avoiding a repeat of the Seattle protests in 1999. However the World Cup is completely different. As one of many world’s most-watched sporting occasions, it’s unattainable to flee assaults, distrust and jealousy… On this respect, Qatar might have realized from Kuwait, which within the late Eighties additionally encountered a storm of protest. The emirate had a conflict chest of $200bn and was in search of bargains on Wall Avenue and the London Inventory Alternate. Lower than a yr after the inventory market crash of Black Monday (19 October 1987), shares in huge multinationals had been low-cost, together with these of British Petroleum (BP), which had not too long ago been privatised by the Thatcher authorities.

In early 1988, the sovereign wealth fund Kuwait Funding Workplace (KIO) provided $2bn for a 22% stake, with a view to taking part in BP’s strategic administration. The thought of an enormous participant from the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Nations (OPEC) having a say in how this British flagship was run precipitated outrage in London. Thatcher threatened Kuwait with reprisals in the event that they elevated their stake and the Labour chief Neil Kinnock warned that the nationwide curiosity was endangered. The KIO finally agreed to cut back its share in BP’s capital.

Within the US, which was already strongly hostile to Japanese buyers, many members of Congress grew to become involved concerning the KIO shopping for up luxurious actual property, particularly in New York. France additionally engaged in ‘Kuwait-bashing’, because it nonetheless hadn’t forgotten the 1982 World Cup in Spain, when the emir’s brother Sheikh Fahad al-Ahmed al-Jaber al-Sabah had come on the pitch on the Valladolid stadium and used his royal standing to have a French objective disallowed, a transfer unprecedented in footballing historical past. This environment of normal distrust meant the KIO needed to spend some huge cash on PR and political lobbying to persuade Western public opinion that Kuwait, nevertheless wealthy and smug it is perhaps, didn’t should be annexed by Saddam Hussein’s Iraq in August 1990.

Kuwait’s leaders realized from these setbacks and have maintained a really low profile on the worldwide stage for 3 many years. Will Qatar do the identical? That can rely upon whether or not the World Cup goes properly and on the conclusions of ongoing investigations. Saudi Arabia, which desires its personal time within the highlight, might even change it within the function of the Gulf’s arch-villain. It’s already contemplating a bid to host the 2030 World Cup, with Egypt and Greece or Morocco as co-hosts. And it has simply been chosen because the venue for the 2029 Asian Winter Video games.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles